Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

The Ultimate Home-Searching Checklist: What to Look For Beyond Square Footage

Posted on: January 8, 2026


When it comes to purchasing a home, especially in exclusive communities like Wynstone in North Barrington, Illinois, many buyers begin their search focused on size—how many bedrooms, how many bathrooms, and total square footage. While these are important factors, they don't always tell the full story of a home’s value, comfort, or long-term suitability. Buyers at the luxury level often require a more nuanced approach to ensure their investment aligns with lifestyle needs, aesthetic preferences, and practical functionality. Understanding what to look for in a new home goes far beyond numbers on a listing sheet.

Location Within the Community

Even within a gated neighborhood like Wynstone, location is paramount. The orientation of the lot, proximity to the golf course, street privacy, and views all contribute significantly to a home's desirability and long-term value. A home on a quiet cul-de-sac with lake or fairway views, for example, often commands a premium over homes with less privacy or less favorable positioning.

Additionally, distance to the clubhouse, walking trails, or community gates may influence day-to-day convenience. Buyers should evaluate how each location within the community affects natural light, traffic flow, and noise levels—factors that contribute directly to livability but are often overlooked in initial online searches.

Layout and Flow of Space

While square footage gives a general sense of scale, it does not address how that space is organized. One of the most important aspects of what to look for in a new home is functional layout. Homes with poor flow—awkward transitions between rooms, underutilized hallways, or disconnected living areas—can feel smaller than their listed size. Conversely, a well-designed home with open sightlines, thoughtful storage, and cohesive design often feels larger and more comfortable.

Today’s buyers frequently look for open-concept kitchens and living areas, flexible rooms that can serve as offices or guest quarters, and primary suites that offer privacy from the rest of the home. In Wynstone, where homes often exceed 4,000 square feet, layout becomes even more critical in determining how comfortably a household can live and grow over time.

Construction Quality and Materials

A large home built with inferior materials may look impressive in photos but can lead to costly repairs and lower resale value down the road. For buyers evaluating what to look for in a new home, construction quality should be a top priority. Details such as solid-core doors, hardwood flooring, high-end window brands, and durable roofing materials often indicate a well-built residence.

In a community like Wynstone, many homes are custom-built, which means construction quality can vary significantly. An experienced local real estate professional can help identify which builders have strong reputations, what materials were commonly used during certain development phases, and whether the home has undergone meaningful updates or structural enhancements.

Storage, Closets, and Functional Utility Areas

Beyond the aesthetics of large living spaces, practical elements like closet space, pantry organization, and laundry room placement play a big role in daily convenience. Buyers often discover after moving in that the home lacks the storage necessary to support their lifestyle. Ample, well-designed closets and built-in shelving can increase functionality and reduce clutter, enhancing overall comfort.

The same is true for garages and utility areas. In North Barrington, where outdoor gear, golf equipment, and seasonal décor are common, having an oversized or heated garage, finished basement storage, or dedicated mudroom can make a home significantly more livable—even if these features don’t add to the official square footage.

Outdoor Living Potential

One of the defining aspects of suburban luxury living is the ability to enjoy the outdoors in privacy and style. Homes in Wynstone often sit on expansive lots with mature landscaping, water views, or golf course frontage. When considering what to look for in a new home, outdoor living space is a key feature that should not be underestimated.

Buyers should evaluate not just the size of the yard, but also how it’s landscaped, whether it includes usable features like patios, decks, or outdoor kitchens, and how easily it connects to the interior living space. Covered seating areas, pools, or even three-season rooms add real value and enhance year-round enjoyment.

Technology and Energy Efficiency

Modern buyers are increasingly prioritizing homes with smart technology and energy efficiency. In higher-end properties, this includes whole-house automation systems, security integration, lighting control, and zoned HVAC systems. These features offer both convenience and cost savings, especially in larger homes where heating, cooling, and electricity can become substantial expenses.

Updated insulation, energy-efficient windows, and newer mechanical systems should also be considered. Buyers who understand what to look for in a new home often focus on these behind-the-walls upgrades, which may not be immediately visible but play a significant role in long-term maintenance and energy bills.

Future Resale Potential

Even if a buyer is planning to live in the home for many years, understanding resale value is always wise. Homes with timeless architecture, neutral design palettes, and adaptable floor plans tend to hold their value better and appeal to a wider range of future buyers. In Wynstone, where many homes are large and uniquely designed, it's important to consider how easily the home could transition to a new owner when the time comes.

This also includes awareness of the local market. North Barrington, and Wynstone in particular, appeals to a specific buyer profile, and homes that balance uniqueness with functionality tend to perform best when it’s time to sell.

The Intangible Factor: How a Home Feels

Finally, there’s the intangible yet critical factor of how the home feels when you walk in. While this can’t be measured in square feet, it often determines whether a property truly feels like “home.” Natural light, ceiling height, architectural detail, and flow all contribute to emotional connection. Experienced buyers and their agents understand that buying a home is both a financial and emotional decision, and finding the right balance is key.

Knowing what to look for in a new home means going beyond the checklist of bedrooms and bathrooms and instead evaluating the elements that support a high-quality lifestyle. From design to location, construction to comfort, it’s the total package that determines whether a home is a wise investment.

Begin Your Home Search With Connie Antoniou

Navigating luxury real estate requires more than browsing listings—it requires insight, local knowledge, and a thoughtful approach to evaluating homes in communities like Wynstone. Buyers who understand what to look for in a new home can make confident decisions that align with both their personal goals and long-term value.

Contact Connie Antoniou today to begin your search in Wynstone and greater North Barrington. With decades of experience and a commitment to personalized service, Connie provides expert guidance through every phase of the home-buying journey. Start exploring your options by visiting Connie Antoniou and team.



Work With Connie

Connie is celebrated in her communities for her unwavering integrity and the exceptional level of service she delivers. From the historic charm of Barrington to the exclusive enclaves of Wynstone, and extending to the scenic beauty of Long Grove, Connie's real estate expertise shines in these sought-after locales. If you're considering buying or selling upscale properties in Wynstone, Barrington, or beyond, Connie is your dedicated partner in navigating the luxury real estate landscape. With her by your side, expect a seamless and personalized experience in these prestigious neighborhoods.

Let's Connect